Index Annuity Advisor
Index Annuity Advisor
  • Home
  • Basics of Annuities
  • Index Annuties
  • Bank Money
  • A Different Approach
  • IRA's
  • What is a Rollover
  • Guaranteed Income
  • Downside to FIA's
  • My Advisor
  • More
    • Home
    • Basics of Annuities
    • Index Annuties
    • Bank Money
    • A Different Approach
    • IRA's
    • What is a Rollover
    • Guaranteed Income
    • Downside to FIA's
    • My Advisor
  • Home
  • Basics of Annuities
  • Index Annuties
  • Bank Money
  • A Different Approach
  • IRA's
  • What is a Rollover
  • Guaranteed Income
  • Downside to FIA's
  • My Advisor

Why Hasn't my Advisor Recommended FIA's

Why Many Financial or Investment Advisors Don’t Recommend Index Annuities

You may wonder why fixed index annuities (FIAs) haven't been recommended by your financial or investment advisors. There are several reasons, and most of them relate to how advisors are compensated.


1. Compensation Structure

Most financial advisors earn income through annual management fees on assets under management (AUM).


  • Typically, advisors charge around 1% of your account balance each year, sometimes more. 
  • These fees are recurring—collected every year, for as long as your money stays in their accounts. 


In contrast, when an FIA is sold, the advisor usually receives a one-time commission, sometimes called a finder’s fee.


  • After that, there is no ongoing payment to the advisor from your account. 
  • From a purely financial standpoint, advisors who earn annual fees have an incentive to keep your money in market-based accounts. 


2. Risk and Market Exposure

With market-based accounts:

  • You assume all the risk of market fluctuations 
  • The advisor earns income regardless of market performance 


With Fixed Index Annuities:

  • The principal is protected, and you may earn market-linked growth 
  • Advisors do not receive ongoing fees, even though the product reduces risk for you 


3. Market Performance Reality

It’s important to look at the data:


  • Studies show that over a 15-20 year period, less than 5% to 8% of actively managed funds and professional advisors consistently beat the market (S&P 500)
  • The vast majority- roughly 92% to 95% - underperform their benchmarks over the long term, particularly after accounting for fees.


Key factors affecting performance include:


  • Management fees charged by the advisor (around 1% annually) 
  • Internal fund expenses inside mutual funds 
  • Inability to consistently pick winning stocks faster than the market average


To outperform the market after fees, an advisor must beat the index by more than their own costs, which is extremely difficult over time.


4. What This Means For You

  • Advisors often recommend market-based accounts that generate recurring fees for them, even though there’s no guarantee you’ll outperform the market. 
  • Fixed index annuities offer market-linked growth with protection and optional lifetime income, but they do not generate ongoing fees for advisors. 
  • This creates a misalignment of incentives: the advisor may benefit more from you staying in market-based accounts than from recommending a protective strategy like an FIA. 


5. Key Takeaway

Choosing a financial product should be based on your goals, risk tolerance, and retirement needs, not on whether it generates ongoing fees for an advisor.


Fixed index annuities can be a powerful tool to protect your assets, grow them tax-deferred, and provide guaranteed lifetime income, but because they don’t produce recurring advisor fees, they are often underrepresented in traditional investment recommendations.


Myth: My advisor does a great job because my account value has been going up over time.  Most individuals don't realize that they could have accomplished the same success and possibly even have greater returns by simply investing in a low cost S&P 500 Index Fund.  


Click below link to see the article from Yahoo Finance describing how "The typical investment adviser can't beat the S&P 500"



Click to read The Typical Investment Adviser Can't Beat the s&p 500
  • Home
  • Basics of Annuities
  • Index Annuties
  • Bank Money
  • A Different Approach
  • IRA's
  • What is a Rollover
  • Guaranteed Income
  • Downside to FIA's
  • My Advisor

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept